The Empathic Wall

“Modern Affect theory begins with the work of Silvan Tomkins (1962, 1963). Observing the face of his newborn son, Tomkins saw what looked like “emotion” displayed on the face of an organism with none of the history, none of the life experience we have always considered necessary for the development of emotion. “Certainly the infant who emits his birth cry upon exit from the birth canal has not ‘appraised’ the new environment as a vale of tears before he cries” (Tomkins, 1982, p. 362). Nonetheless, the crying infant looks quite like a crying adult this cry of distress must have been available to the infant courtesy of some pre-existent mechanism triggered by some stimulus acceptable to that mechanism.”

Written in 1986 by Don Nathanson, The Empathic Wall and the Ecology of Affect originally appeared in The Psychoanalytic Study of the Child.

Download the article now.

Donald Nathanson

For too long those who explain emotional discomfort on the basis of lived experience and those who blame chemistry have been at loggerheads.

As Dr. Nathanson shows, chemicals and illnesses can affect our mood just as surely as an uncomfortable memory or a stern rebuke.

Linking for the first time the affect theory of the pioneering researcher Silvan S. Thomkins with the entire world of biology, medicine, psychology, psychotherapy, religion, and the social sciences, Dr. Nathanson presents a completely new understanding of all emotion.

Drawing on every theme of the modern life sciences, Donald Nathanson shows how nine basic affects—interest-excitement, enjoyment-joy, surprise-startle, fear-terror, distress-anguish, anger-rage, dissmell, disgust, and shame-humiliation—not only determine how we feel but shape our very sense of self.

This is a revolutionary book about the nature of emotion, about the way emotions are triggered in our private moments, in our relations with others, and by our biology.